Offline
The box was still red on the outside
Last edited by Eastcoast (10/27/2016 10:55 pm)
Offline
Eastcoast wrote:
BBB,
I really thought we were going to get to see Samar let her have it! oh well....
Show-runners guilty of depriving us of a natural outcome! However, Elise is still alive - maybe upon further interrogations Samar will untie her in order to wreak havoc! I think Elise was probably the least surprising thing we've ever had on TBL - everyone knew she was a plant!
Offline
lara1 and tuxie, I think the baby just looks older. They do change a lot in a few weeks time.
Offline
BBB,
that's the truth! I thought that was funny When he said what part of banana didn't you understand.
And yes, I am thinking later we might get to see Samar " Interrogate " her.
Offline
Samar and Ressler (particularly Ressler) have been the major casualties of the current story-lines. And Tom was reduced to nothing but an errand boy tonite - thanks for showing up Tom....
Samar did manage to sneak in a few expressions and hot lines - her smiling at the end with Aram eating remnants from the post office fridge was priceless (short but priceless)
Offline
lara1 wrote:
well I wonder if Red planted that DNA report.....stranger things have happened!!!
LOL! I was thinking the same thing!
Offline
lara1 wrote:
Tuxie400 - Kirk in the box - mirror images again of Red! and didn't the frame of the box look white?
Red and white - color theme running through the series.......hmmmm
I read or heard something about the box. It's either not the original box or it was looking different because it's not located on its original set. Something that affects the way it can be lit when they film it. Can't remember where I read that.
Offline
Tuxie400 wrote:
Liz used her superpower - profiling - to get Agnes back. Now if she would just use it more effectively on Red.
.
It looks to me like the entire thing was planned to capture Kirk. Including Liz's "defection" at the last. You can bet your sweet bippy that Liz is using her superpower on Red. All that about Kirk being the only one left, besides Red, who could tell her the truth about herself. She was really working on him and I got the impression that he was really fighting wanting to tell her. You could see it in his face.
Offline
lara1 wrote:
eastcoast #69 in a very round about way this kind of leads back to Red possibly being the father.
Liz was not Kirk's to raise; Kirk "cannot have" Agnes....interesting words. and east coast, those words you note, Red took Katarina away and took Liz away. So maybe Katarina did run off with Raymond. And maybe he was the "American".
Maybe that is what Red is worried about, that Liz will figure out the full truth ....or something! LOL
The only problem is that it can't be that simple. So Red had an affair with a married KGB agent. She had a baby, possibly his. How is that so "complicated" that he can't tell his possible kid anything about it all these years later? they are all adults now. Surely it can't be that he just can't admit that to her. No. There's got to be a really good twist to the story and Liz knows that Red is the one she has to dig that information out of. Don't forget she is supposed to be a psychologist and a profiler. Once she gets a chance to slow down and regain her balance she ought to be able to get her questions answered. But Red sees to it that she is kept enough off balance that she has a hard time working on him. Plus she's good at being her own worst enemy most of the time. Anyway, Red told her in the beginning that there were truths out there that she would need to discover for herself.
Offline
I think that was one of their better episodes. I REALLY need to watch it again.
Just a couple of preliminary thoughts.
I am so glad that they didn't drag out the Elise as mole story for too long. And I like the way they were all concerned about Aram learning the truth and then he comes in all angry after finding out that truth on his own.
The all analog office was interesting. No digital footprints to follow. Do you suppose that was Red's own communications center?
The Liz/Red scenes were great. Right back into the show's old groove. We've sort of been missing that lately with them being separated for so long.
I am intrigued by Mr. Kaplan's captor. He seems like this sort of backwoods living off the land hermit sort of guy, but he has some technology. Well, at least he has those wildlife cameras. That could be to help him hunt for game, but then there might be more to him than that. But, in any case, he knows about Red and Dembe and it looked like he got some pretty good close ups of Red. As in, he could ID him. A little scary his echoing of what Red said "What am I going to do with you?"
Oh, you can bet that Cooper knows more about Red's doings than he lets on. He may not know the details, but he knows he has a part to play in whatever is really going on. I thought that was interesting when Red told him that Kirk was not on the blacklist until he came after Liz. But I still wonder - Kirk was not on the list, but was Rostov? Red had to know he was still out there and was a possible danger. Or is he just a bonus now that he's been captured? My bet is that he's going to escape before they get any info out of him.
More later after my rewatch.
Offline
Ah, no wonder it was so good. Teleplay by Daniel Knauf. Story by Daniel Knauf and Dave Metzger.
Offline
Red: ...Our sole concession to the digital revolution is the Ms. PacMan machine in the break room.
Cooper: But why?
Red: Because I like Ms. PacMan.
Red: we set the bait, he took it.
Cooper: a human sacrifice.
Red: I prefer the term "tethered goat".
Last edited by Honey West (10/28/2016 3:26 am)
Offline
Okay, Kirk agreed with Red that it had to end now and then took a shot at him, grazing his arm. Is Kirk really a bad shot or did he do that on purpose? He intended to kill Red, but when he had the chance to actually do it himself, he basically missed. It reminded me of the time that Tom also "missed". And we know Tom is a good shot. I'm starting to wonder if Red is made of teflon. Or Kevlar. The Cabal's sniper even had a clear shot at him and couldn't get the job done. Of course, the obvious answer is you can't kill off the star of the show. (ermm)
Offline
The music when Baz and Co. first appear is so so hilariously awesome. My husband seems to think Ressler and Elise were looking cozy in the questioning room. Not so much that they could be working together, but that she's not bad to look at if he (my husband) got tasked with that job. I'm not worried, she'd ninja kick his ass. ;)
This was probably the best episode so far this season. I'm confused now, but in a good way, and didn't get mad at my tv/writers this week. I just don't understand how Liz didn't want to push Kirk off the ledge after retrieving Agnes. Father or not, knower of all secrets or not, HE TOOK YOUR BABY LADY!!!! And was Tom on a lunch break? Where was he when Agnes was recovered? Will Agnes and dad be moving to Redemption in this place that will not be guarded by Red's Team?
I kind of liked that Kirk wasn't on the BL until Red felt he threatened Liz (and possibly his) safety and/or guarded secrets. That means we could have surprise BListers popup and not just ones that are written in "Redbook". Final thought, how close are Panabaker and Cooper? I kind of got the feeling he gave her the "eyes" when they were discussing playing poker (?????)? I forget Mrs. Cooper's name (Charlene?), but I though they had reconciled or were trying to at the end of S3.
Offline
Honey West - really enjoyed reading your posts as usual. # 90 - my views as well. # 93 - Teflon Red. LOL. but that's an interesting observation.
Patter # 94 - I'm wondering if there is another reason why Kirk was not on Red's Blacklist - did he not know that Kirk was Constantin and/or did we think he was in fact dead? But based on their interactions and what Red knew of Kirk back in Season 3, it doesn't seem that way. And, he did add Kirk as #14. Not sure I know what the numbers really represent, but if the higher the number, the more dangerous to Red's endgame (whatever it is) I would have expected Red to slot Kirk in at a higher number. It really does make me think there is more to it (why Kirk was not on the Blacklist) than what Red said and whether the Blacklist and Red's endgame is different to what we may have thought previously.
Last edited by lara1 (10/28/2016 12:51 pm)
Offline
I echo the views of those above who think this was an excellent episode. I walked away thinking "What just happened" and I am confused, and agree with Patter (#94) that is a good thing! I also think that we are in for a huge Fall finale, the tension is almost palpable!
The biggest puzzle for me thus far in the Season remains Red's words to Kirk about Liz not being Kirk's to raise, and Kirk not being able to "have" Agnes (and Kirk seems to agree with the latter which is why he is on the ledge in the first place?). Why and what do those words mean? Especially as in private, away from Liz, Kirk has referred to Liz as his daughter and, to Red, Agnes as his granddaughter. And Harold's words to Red in private.
I feel like there is a large construct here about to be revealed, because some things add up and some things negate the others.
Honey West - #88 - I like your observation about Liz profiling Red. It makes me wonder whether some of her outbursts in the past have been to try to bait him - and he has successfully ignored them. Now things seem to be rising to the tipping point and about to boil over. I also think that at this point Red is pained to hold back what he wants to say. In Season 3, when Liz confronted him with the photo that Velov found when tracking Katarina, Red looked like he wanted to speak but checked himself. Now it looks like he's really fighting against it. I wonder if something will spill out before the finale?
Offline
First of all, welcome and welcome back to new/old members! I check the member list every once in awhile and it's always nice to see new and new/old names appear on there!
Great posts, everyone! Too many to call each of you out on, but my typical M.O. after watching the show is to go on the forum and first read all of what each of you wrote. I like this new quoting thing so it's easy to "play along" and reply as if I was watching it with you all. Then I write something with first thoughts and reactions, before I go back and check things. If I can stay up long enough, I watch the main parts of the episode again where I think I need clarification, then add a comment or two. Then I go and read Jodi Walker's recap on the Entertainment Weekly site, because it's usually there by then. And compare with what I got out of the story. Then I go sleep for awhile and get up the next morning and read more comments on here because you all are mostly 2-3 hours ahead of me.
So, I have to say I really like the Red scenes that Daniel Knauf writes. I feel that he has a good handle on who the real Red is, where he's come from and where he thinks he's going. The scene with Cooper and Red was excellent. Not a lot of words, but a lot of feeling and depth in what was said. Red had no idea when he turned himself in how badly things would go. And things just keep getting worse. He's been forced to basically lock Liz up for her own safety but he realizes that he is suffocating her. And that seems like it wasn't supposed to happen that way and he knows it's not right. Cooper seems to know more than we thought. I suspect he knows what Red is really all about. Maybe not every detail, but he knows what he needs to know in order to maintain the Task Force's role. And there have been indications that others know it, too. We, the audience, are not among that group, though, we get to guess along with Liz and as things are revealed to her, then we will find out, too. Her character is our representative. We do get clues that Liz doesn't, though, like Red's scars, the letter he burned, etc., so we get pulled into the story in a slightly different way, and also if all we had was what Liz knows, it might not keep us quite as interested in the plot. Everybody loves a good guessing game, and there's plenty of that for all of us, that's for sure!
Offline
And Terrence O'Hara also directed Kings of the Highway.
Offline
Honey West #97 - reading your post and thinking about Red and Harold's conversation, I was wondering what are your thoughts on Red being deep deep cover? With maybe Harold being the, or at least, a, facilitator? I think during the summer break that was discussed a bit - the idea of Red being very deep undercover - I can't recall whether it was you or someone else who may have mentioned that theory. Recent developments may start to point in that direction. But how it would tie in to the whole Rostov/Rostova story I don't know.
I also feel like the series is gearing up for a major 180 degree turn in course or maybe even a 360 as we get more reveals and pieces of info from now up through the fall finale.
A re-watch of this episode is definitely in order this weekend!
Offline
Honey West #97 - I agree that Knauf writes excellent Red scenes. I liked the one with Harold too. It shows that Red realizes what's happened with Liz. What Kaplan told him seem to have gotten through to him. I also liked the dialog when Red was trying to talk Kirk off the ledge.